Human-Centric Predictive Model of Task Difficulty for Human-In-The-Loop Control Tasks



Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title


Public Library of Science


Quantitatively measuring the difficulty of a manipulation task in human-in-the-loop control systems is ill-defined. Currently, systems are typically evaluated through task-specific performance measures and post-experiment user surveys; however, these methods do not capture the real-time experience of human users. In this study, we propose to analyze and predict the difficulty of a bivariate pointing task, with a haptic device interface, using human-centric measurement data in terms of cognition, physical effort, and motion kinematics. Noninvasive sensors were used to record the multimodal response of human user for 14 subjects performing the task. A data-driven approach for predicting task difficulty was implemented based on several task-independent metrics. We compare four possible models for predicting task difficulty to evaluated the roles of the various types of metrics, including: (I) a movement time model, (II) a fusion model using both physiological and kinematic metrics, (III) a model only with kinematic metrics, and (IV) a model only with physiological metrics. The results show significant correlation between task difficulty and the user sensorimotor response. The fusion model, integrating user physiology and motion kinematics, provided the best estimate of task difficulty (R² = 0.927), followed by a model using only kinematic metrics (R² = 0.921). Both models were better predictors of task difficulty than the movement time model (R² = 0.847), derived from Fitt’s law, a well studied difficulty model for human psychomotor control.



Human-computer interaction, Haptic devices, Motor ability--Testing, Psychomotor Performance

National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under award Number UL1TR001105


CC BY 4.0 (Attribution), ©2018 The Authors